Surrogacy: Have we really progressed to “made to order” babies?

December 13, 2009 by Cathy Ribble  
Filed under: News

F-It!
 

Leave a comment

After years of infertility, Amy Kehoe and her husband, Scott, became desperate to “create” a baby, causing untold numbers to question their “made to order” method.  Some would even call Amy Kehoe a “general contractor.”  The story which unfolded brings many ethical and moral questions to the practice of third-party reproduction.

Generally speaking, a “general contractor” talks to subs they might want to work with.  They look at qualifications, they accept bids, sign a contract, and let the subs perform the contracted work.

Amy Kehoe picked out a pre-med student from the University of Michigan to be an egg donor.  She then selected an anonymous sperm donor from the web site California Cryobank.  His qualifications were a 4.0 high school grade-point average and athletic.

Then Amy Kehoe found someone to carry and deliver her baby, also known as a surrogate.  She also located a fertility clinic which would “assemble” her baby.

The couple paid for the egg, the sperm. as well as a surrogate willing to undergo in vitro fertilization.  While their roles did not include traditional methods of procreation, Kehoe said, “They wouldn’t be here if it weren’t for us.”

On July 28, the Kehoes welcomed the birth of Ethan and Bridget at University Hospital in Ann Arbor, Michigan.  The happy family went home from the hospital on August 3 to meet the rest of their family.  But the question arises, “Exactly who was their extended family?”

The surrogate mother, Laschell Baker, of Ypsilanti, Michigan, then learned that Amy Kehoe was being treated for mental illness.  She filed for and obtained a court order to take custody of Bridget and Ethan.  After having the babies in their home for approximately one month, the Kehoes were forced to relinquish custody to.  The twins will now be raised by Laschell Baker and her husband, Paul.

“I couldn’t see living the rest of my life worrying and wondering what had happened, or what if she hadn’t taken her medicine, or what if she relapsed,” said Mrs. Baker, who has four children of her own.

According to the New York Times piece written on this story, approximately 750 babies are born each year in the United States through gestational surrogacy.  Some reports claim that more than twice that many surrogate pregnancies are attempted.

The birth of this set of twins raised many challenging questions for the best of family law — or contract law — lawyers.  Instead of the normal two, or maybe even three, people involved in the birth of a child, more than five parties were involved in Ethan and Bridget’s creation and birth:  the egg donor, the sperm donor, Laschell Baker (and her husband), Amy and Scott Kehoe, as well as the two separate services which brokered the egg and the sperm.

The profound legal implications may haunt these two innocent children the rest of their lives.

To read more about the legal complexities of surrogacy, read the following:

21st Century Babies:  The Gift of Life and Its Price

21st Century Babies: Risky Path to Parenthood

21st Century Babies:  Made to Order

[Post to Twitter]  [Post to Delicious]  [Post to Digg]  [Post to Reddit]  [Post to StumbleUpon] 

Welcome back! If you love Baby Chums, please subscribe to our RSS feed.
Thanks for dropping by and enjoy!


Read More related stories...
Babies for sale - A story of surrogacy and poverty
Indian clinics have become baby making factories in a multi-million...
You Tube Laughing Babies Make Us Smile
By his own admission, Boston Globe columnist James Parker admits...
21-year-old sperm produces baby for IVF couple in USA
A North Carolina, USA, couple welcomed a baby last month...
Your Ad Here
Bambino Direct

Comments

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!





Recent Posts

Courtney Loses Custody of Her 17 Year Old Daughter Frances BeanCourtney Loses Custody of Her 17 Year Old Daughter Frances Bean

Courtney Love has once again lost legal guardianship of her daughter Frances Bean Cobain. Frances Bean, who is the daughter... »

Pregnant women able to better distinguish emotions in othersPregnant women able to better distinguish emotions in others

Pregnant women may be better at reading the emotions on people's faces, especially late in the pregnancy. While hormonal... »

Writer Cecilia Ahern Gives Birth to a GirlWriter Cecilia Ahern Gives Birth to a Girl

Celilia Ahern and her partner David Keoghan are first time parents as she gives birth to their daughter. The little girl,... »

Usher Looking Forward to Celebrating the Holidays With His Two SonsUsher Looking Forward to Celebrating the Holidays With His Two Sons

The Grammy-award winning singing is looking forward to Christmas this year and spending it with his two sons. Even though... »

Reality Star Kourtney Kardashian Welcomes a SonReality Star Kourtney Kardashian Welcomes a Son

The Keeping Up with the Kardashians star gave birth to her first child on Monday, December 14th in Los Angeles. It's a boy... »

Army major united with baby son for first time upon returning from AfghanistanArmy major united with baby son for first time upon returning from Afghanistan

Army Major William Waugh and the other soldiers of EGYPT returned to the UK from Afghanistan, reuniting with loved ones. As... »

New Irish Web site launched for teens thinking about having sexNew Irish Web site launched for teens thinking about having sex

A new Web site launched by Ireland's Crisis Pregnancy Agency provides useful and non-judgmental information to teenagers... »

Surrogacy:  Have we really progressed to “made to order” babies?Surrogacy: Have we really progressed to “made to order” babies?

After years of infertility, Amy Kehoe and her husband, Scott, became desperate to "create" a baby, causing untold numbers to... »

Cheryl Cole to Quit X-Factor to Have a Baby?Cheryl Cole to Quit X-Factor to Have a Baby?

This may be Cheryl Cole's last season judging on the X-Factor as she wants to focus on her family and try for a baby... »

Actor Ryan Thomas Gets Arrested after Heated Row with Ex Over DaughterActor Ryan Thomas Gets Arrested after Heated Row with Ex Over Daughter

The Coronation Street star was taken into police custody after a heated row with his ex-girlfriend Tina O'Brien when she came... »

    ITN News Entertainment Videos

    Loading...