Your viewing articles about; High Court
Baby RB’s father gives up fight to keep son on life support
November 11, 2009 by Shawn Douglas
Filed under News
Baby RB’s father agreed with the mother and medical experts that removal of life support was the best option after hearing six days of testimony.
Baby RB, born with a debilitating genetic defect that causes muscles to malfunction, will be taken off life support after the father withdrew his opposition to the action, originally proposed by the mother.
The High Court’s Justice McFarlane gave a lengthy and carefully-worded statement, praising the estranged couple — identified only as Ms. KM and Mr. AB — for their dedication to their son’s plight.
Justice McFarlane said: “It is a fact that K and A have spent the most part of each and every day of the last 13 months at RB’s bedside, doing what they can to care for him, and, when the opportunity arises, to interest and stimulate him, seizing upon any sign of a spark and trying to develop it into something more.”
“They have put their adult lives on hold. The stress has been immense. It has cost them their relationship, but they still work together and do what they can to support their son.”
“When faced with the awfulness of the situation in which they found themselves, these two young people have stepped up to the plate and discharged the responsibility that life had thrust upon them by each showing 100 percent commitment to their child in a manner which can only command profound respect and admiration.”
The father changed his mind about maintaining life support after hearing six days of testimony from medical experts, most agreeing that his son’s condition will likely never improve. Most testimony given expressed concerns that the child couldn’t communicate his pain.
In a joint statement issued by the lawyers of the parents and the hospital, the couple said: “Although we are separated, we have always been united in wanting the best possible care for our son so that he may have the best quality of life. We have been at his bedside daily these last 13 months. We now wish to spend what little time remains with our beloved son.”
With the finalization of the order by the High Court, Baby RB will be given a sedative and then taken off life support in the next few days.
Welcome back! If you love Baby Chums, please subscribe to our RSS feed.
Thanks for dropping by and enjoy!
Ofsted apologizes ‘unreservedly’ for error in Baby P case
November 10, 2009 by Shawn Douglas
Filed under News
Ofsted has apologized to the court for its ‘deeply regrettable error’ of failing to disclose an inspection report and other documents related to the Baby P case.
Childcare regulator Ofsted’s failure to provide potentially key evidence to the High Court will likely delay judgment of the Sharon Shoesmith case until the end of the year or later said Justice Foskett earlier today.
Originally set to deliver a judgment on Friday, Justice Foskett called a special hearing upon learning that Shoesmith’s legal team produced anticipated evidence through a Freedom of Information Act request. The team had been previously told that the evidence — a 70-page notebook, assorted e-mails and early drafts of the inspection report — did not exist.
Justice Foskett demanded “chapter and verse” on why the evidence had not been previously provided.
“Unfortunately mistakes sometimes happen and whilst this is a serious one and deeply regrettable, we have nothing to hide,” said Ofsted in a statement.
James Maurici, appearing on the behalf of Shoesmith, was very concerned about the “very serious failings on the part of Ofsted in relation to its duty of candor and its response to our requests for further information”.
Maurici added: “They must have known these things existed. It is very worrying this has transpired.”
Shoesmith was fired from her position as children’s services chief last December after a report condemned the department for its handling of the Baby P case.
Justice Foskett ordered Ofsted to pay for both the hearing costs and the cost of Shoesmith’s legal team to sift through the new evidence to determine its relevance.
Father withdraws opposition in Baby RB Right-To-Die trial
November 10, 2009 by Baby Chums
Filed under News
Baby RB’s father has withdrawn his opposition to the mother’s High Court plea for the child’s life support machine to be turned off.
The couple, who separated amicably, had asked the High Court to make the decision over whether the baby should be kept alive.
However, today the father unexpectedly withdrew his opposition, meaning the ventilator keeping the baby alive will now be switched off.
Mr Justice McFarlane said it was a “sad but in my view inevitable outcome”.
It was the “only tenable one for RB”.
As the judge summarized the tragic case, both parents wept and the mother at one point left the court in tears but returned to hear his tribute to them and the doctors and nurses caring for their son.
The hospital authority had sought a court order allowing RB to die with dignity rather than continuing to live what doctors described as a “miserable and pitiful” existence.
The court heard from counsel that the father, KM, had come to the decision “after a very great deal of thought after hearing all the evidence as it has developed in this case”.
After being told that all the parties were now in agreement about the course to be taken, the judge said: “It is appropriate for me to say one or two words, not in judgment, but in endorsement of this sad but, in my view, inevitable outcome.”
He said: “It is, I suspect, impossible for those of us to whom such an event has not happened to do more than guess at the impact of it upon these two young parents.
“In one moment all of the hopes and dreams that they will have had for their expected baby will have been dashed and replaced with a life characterized by worry, stress, exhaustion, confusion and no doubt great sadness.”
He said: “During the past 13 months both KM and AB have discharged their responsibility to their son in a manner which has been described by all who have seen it in superlative terms.”
The judge went on: “It is a fact that K and A have spent the most part of each and every day of the last 13 months at RB’s bedside, doing what they can to care for him and, when the opportunity arises, to interest and stimulate him, seizing upon any sign of a spark and trying to develop it into something more.
“They have put their own adult lives on hold. The stress has been immense, it has cost them their relationship, but still they work together and do what they can to support their son.
“When faced with the awfulness of the situation in which they found themselves, these two young people have stepped up to the plate and discharged the responsibility that life had thrust upon them by each showing 100% commitment to their child in a manner which can only command profound respect and admiration.”
The move comes a day after Professor Andrew Bush of paediatric respirology at Imperial College London, said a mother’s wishes should outweigh those of a father.
Prof Bush told the court: “Not to trivialize the views of the father, but most paediatricians would find it very, very difficult to overrule a mother.”
Baby RB suffers from congenital myasthenic syndrome, in which the signal between the nerves and the muscles is impaired, making it difficult to move. His brain functions normally, but he cannot communicate or interact with his parents.
Right-to-die-trial Baby RB: A mother’s wishes outweigh a father’s opinion
November 9, 2009 by Baby Chums
Filed under Baby Health, News
A mother’s wishes over her child’s care outweigh a father’s opinion, a right-to-die trial was told yesterday.
The mother, Miss KM, agrees with the doctors view, that his quality of life is so poor that he should be allowed to die in peace, his father, Mr RB, believes everything must be done to keep their child alive. The child, known as Baby RB is unable to swallow or breathe unaided and so is reliant on a ventilator around the clock.
The High Court has to make the heart-breaking decision for them, Mr Justice McFarlane presides.
Internationally renowned respiratory paediatrician, Prof Bush, who has been a consultant for almost two decades, said of the mother’s view:
“As a paediatrician, I think the views of the mother should always be taken very, very seriously,
“Not to trivialise the views of the father, but most paediatricians would find it very, very difficult to overrule a mother.”
Representing Mr RB, Martin Westgate, asked whether it was because she was the mother, or because Miss KM supported the medical view that life support should be withdrawn.
“It is because it’s the mother that I put particular weight on her views,” he said.
“If the mother expresses a view to me in my ordinary clinical practice, that’s something I take very, very seriously indeed… and the father as well.
“I try to give considerable weight to his views. He clearly loves his son and is very devoted. He has clearly spent many hours by his bedside, trying to interact with his son.”
Mr RB’s lawyers called in the consultant professor of paediatric respirology at Imperial College London.
They argue that a tracheostomy would enable his son to leave hospital and be cared for at home.
Initially, Mr Westgate said Prof Bush might be willing to perform the procedure but having visited Baby RB this weekend, the consultant clarified his position.
“My conclusion was that Baby RB best interests would not be served by a tracheostomy and ventilation at home,” he said.
“My greatest worry in these circumstances is a child whose neurological condition progresses and is not able to communicate.
“They have a normal brain inside a completely immobile and incommunicative body - so called locked-in syndrome.”
Prof Bush said a tracheostomy would only prolong his life and not cure his condition.
“My concern about the treatment is that as he gets older and develops that he will become increasingly frustrated about his inability to communicate, his inability to interact.”
“The boy would probably develop curvature of the spine and other medical problems, and would be unable to communicate his pain,” said Prof Bush.
The court heard how Baby RB, who is not expected to reach his third birthday, had deteriorated in the last seven days, with his muscles weakening even further. Baby RB suffers from a congenital myasthenic syndrome, where the signal between the nerves and the muscles don’t work properly, making it difficult to move.
His primary nurse, Nurse P, who cannot be named for legal reasons, said he used to be able to open his eyes and move his arms, but had not done so for weeks.
She said: “If you put a toy in his hands, he will grasp his fingers around the toy, but quite quickly loses his grip.
“The only movement I have seen is if I have supported Baby RB, I have held his hands and clapped them together.”
Referring to Miss KM and Mr RB, she said: “They are brilliant, they are great parents. They love him dearly, they are constantly at his bedside.
“They both clearly want what they feel is best for Baby RB.”
As Nurse P gave her evidence, Miss KM leaned forward and listened carefully with tears in her eyes.
The case continues.
Father fights hospital’s bid to remove his baby’s life support
November 1, 2009 by Shawn Douglas
Filed under News
A father is fighting to keep his one-year-old son, suffering from a neuromuscular condition, on life support.
On Monday, the father of Baby RB will go to London’s High Court tomorrow to argue that his son deserves to remain on life support. The hospital providing the services has asked for a court order to remove the child from the breathing apparatus that keeps him alive.
Baby RB suffers from a rare neuromuscular condition called congenital myasthenic syndrome. The condition causes the signals between nerve endings and muscles to be much weaker than normal, creating abnormally weak muscles in the afflicted.
If the hospital wins its argument in the High Court, it will mark the first time that a British court has terminated life support—against a parent’s wishes—of a child that doesn’t suffer from brain damage.
Lawyers representing the father have stated that the baby doesn’t suffer brain deficiencies due to the condition, has fully functional senses, and can recognize his parents.
“The father feels very strongly that Baby RB has a quality of life that demands the trust should continue to provide life-sustaining treatment,” said Christopher Cuddihee, speaking on behalf of the father.
The father clearly adores his son and hopes to demonstrate to the court that the trust’s application should be rejected.”
However, the father’s fight is being resisted by the mother of Baby RB. The baby’s mother, who is “amicably separated” from the father, supports the actions of the hospital.
The father plans to put forth evidence during the hearing that his son would benefit from a simple tracheostomy, a procedure that would allow his son to be discharged from the hospital and cared for in the home. In addition, he hopes that video montages, photographs, and recorded interactions with the baby will lend strength to his case.
As sad as these cases may seem, there is often little recourse other than the legal system to resolve such conflicts.
“When the parents and the clinical team don’t agree on the treatment for the child in question, the only way forward is to go to the courts and for the courts to decide on what is in the best interests of the child, which is paramount,” a spokeswoman for the British Medical Association told the Guardian.
“Baby OT” battling for life in the high court
March 20, 2009 by Baby Chums
Filed under Baby Health, News
Update *** 21st March at 11:00
Baby OT was unable to breathe by himself and died at 1008 GMT after doctors withdrew his treatment.
***
Update ***
Two Court of Appeal judges have now refused the couple permission to challenge a decision by Mrs Justice Parker.
***
Parents fighting to keep nine month old, “Baby OT” alive with a serious condition have lodged an appeal against a High Court ruling which has allowed him to die.
Baby OT has a rare metabolic disorder which has resulted in him suffering respiratory failure, brain damage and is being kept alive on a ventilator.
A judge, Mrs. Justice Parker, ruled on Thursday that it was in the best interests of the baby for the NHS trust involved to withdraw, “Life sustaining treatment”. She said: “I bear in mind that OT is a unique human being . His life is valuable. But OT does not have the right to be kept alive in all circumstances. OT has the right to life. OT does not have the right to be kept alive.”
Mrs. Justice Parker also gave doctors and nurses treating Baby OT the right not to keep him alive with further painful invasive treatment after one of the doctors said what they were doing amounted to “torture.”
Neither the baby nor the trust involved in the case can be identified.







