Maternity leave rights in the UK could be double-edged sword for women

October 20, 2009 by Shawn Douglas  
Filed under: News, Pregnancy

 

Leave a comment

Maternity leaves of up to a year coupled with uncapped penalties for successful sexual discrimination claims may be costing working women jobs and money.

Ever since Nichola Pease, deputy chairman of J O Hambro Capital Management, told the Treasury Committee that women are in danger of having their maternity leave “backfire” on them, discussion has been very animated across the U.K. Many of the discussions have come in the form of editorials, blogs, and news stories that ask women to be more responsible with their maternity rights.

While the topic has been in discussion for many months, Nichola Pease likely opened the floodgates with her comments to the committee.

“A year maternity leave is too long, and sex discrimination claims that run into tens of millions of pounds are ridiculous,” Pease told the Treasury Committee on October 14.

“What I worry about is that legislation and protection turns this into a nightmare. We’ve got to be realistic and make sure the protection, which has very good motivation, doesn’t end up backfiring both at a female level and at a U.K. competitiveness level.”

Her comments came as the Treasury Committee was investigating the factors involved with why women who work in the financial-services industry earn less than men. Additionally, the committee wanted to address why women gain fewer executive-level jobs than men.

But aren’t women important to the U.K. workforce? Times columnist Eleanor Mills made an interesting observation in her Sunday column.

“It is crucial that we as a society get this legislation right; there are now 172,925 female undergraduates and only 141,643 male ones,” said Mills. “Mothers in the workforce are here to stay.”

With slightly more than 1.2 young women for each young man in the workforce, Mills is right; the U.K. can’t ignore the importance of women in the workplace. But a certain level of responsibility must be had when dealing with maternity leave.

Mills illustrated that point by relating the story of a woman placed in a prominent FTSE company who took a year’s maternity leave, fought for a promotion upon returning, and then got the promotion. Two months later, the woman announced she was pregnant again and would take another year of maternity leave.

Mills isn’t alone in her calls for responsibility. India Lenon, an Oxford University student and blogger for the Telegraph, expressed her own concerns about how the maternity leave policy and women that use it may affect her future. While she ranks having a baby as “low” on her priority list, she realizes that businesses may look at her and other young women as “peak-fertility time-bombs” regardless of priorities.

“It’s a bitter pill to swallow that while we attempt, upon graduation, to find a place on the housing ladder, perhaps a partner, but above all a job, the stages of our lives that haven’t even occurred to us yet might be standing in our way,” said Lenon.

She went on to say that “employers who pick a young man over a young woman are not chauvinists; they are using their common sense.”

And many men and women who have commented on the situation seem to agree; there has been a small but noticeable shift from discrimination of women based upon perceived lack of ability to a discrimination based upon capacity of giving birth.

One commenter on Eleanor Mills’ blog mentions his four-year-old business with two young female employees who are in long-term relationships and his concerns about hiring another woman. He fears that he may leave his business “vulnerable” if he hires another woman and one or even two of them take a year of maternity leave.

As more women abuse the system, these fears will continue to rise in hiring managers and working or soon-to-be-working women alike. Calls for moderation and responsibility will get louder as the double-edged sword of the current government maternity policy gets sharper.

[Post to Twitter]  [Post to Delicious]  [Post to Digg]  [Post to Reddit]  [Post to StumbleUpon] 

Welcome back! If you love Baby Chums, please subscribe to our RSS feed.
Thanks for dropping by and enjoy!


Read More related stories...
Women in UK Faced With Serious Maternity Ward Problems
Last year over 3,500 women in the UJ were forced...
Cute Babies - Only a woman knows
Females are much better at identifying a cute baby than...
Soldier hides baby in barracks
A female soldier, 20, who hid her pregnancy has given...
Your Ad Here
Bambino Direct

Comments

Tell us what you're thinking...
and oh, if you want a pic to show with your comment, go get a gravatar!





Recent Posts

Heene Family not the only one’s to try and cash in on their Balloon Boy

A Canadian company are following the Heene Families footsteps to cash in on a hoax by creating a, "Balloon Boy" Halloween... »

Baby Trafficking Ring Breakthrough as Smugglers arrested in Bulgaria

Police in Bulgaria have arrested a married couple in their late thirtees beleived to have trafficked pregnant women from... »

Gisele Bundchen and Tom Brady Expecting a Girl

The supermodel and the professional athlete are said to be expecting a girl in late December. An insider tells Life... »

Robin Thicke is Going to Be a Dad

Robin Thicke and  his wife Paula Patton are expecting their first child. According to reports from usmagazine.com, Robin... »

Charlotte Church’s Toddler Daughters Suffers From Breath Holding Spells During Tantrums

Charlotte Church fears her daughter's medical condition as the toddler holds her breath during tantrums, causing her to... »

Womb transplants may become a reality in as little as 2 years

Womb transplants could potentially help women who were born without a womb or who suffered uterine damage have a... »

Dangerous dummies recalled

Fourteen dangerous dummies have been recalled by the government of Australia's New South Wales due to being a choking hazard to... »

Premature Baby Boy Delivered After Chicago Mom Killed

Kim Brown was killed yesterday when she was struck by a van while walking on a sidewalk near a Chicago intersection, and her... »

Devastation: Body of Somer Thompson Found

Words do not seem adequate to describe the devastation and shock felt by the family, authorities and search volunteers who... »

Baby of, “Fat Family” from Dundee, Scotland taken into, “Care”

A highly controversial case of Scotland's so-called "fat family" took a dramatic twist yesterday, when a council moved to take... »